When it comes to shopping for a new car, the compact utility vehicle segment is a great place to start. This segment offers more than a dozen choices, with the Honda CR-V and the Toyota RAV4 vying for leadership. Both models are prized for their style, versatility, and good prices. But when it comes to reliability, the edge goes to the Honda CR-V.
Honda CR-V Versus Toyota RAV4
Both the Honda CR-V and the Toyota RAV4 are established compact crossover sport utility vehicles. These two models are among the first in the segment; both have undergone extensive overhauls since being introduced in the 1990s.
Before we tackle reliability, there are some common denominators that define this segment. First, most compact SUVs come with standard front-wheel drive and available all-wheel drive, the latter is ideal for customers living in snowy locations, such as Wisconsin. In any case, winter tires help provide traction and stability throughout the cold months.
Second, both the Honda and Toyota offer standard gas-powered models or an available hybrid. Not all competitors offer both choices, giving customers a more efficient option with the hybrid. Indeed, you'll find a 10 mpg advantage with the Honda hybrid over the gas model.
Third, models in this segment routinely seat five passengers, with ample cargo space behind the second-row seat. Indeed, with 75.6 cubic feet of cargo space with the rear seat folded, the CR-V beats the RAV4, and leads the segment. Incidentally, both models tow up to 1,500 pounds when properly equipped.
Fourth, both models are affordable, with prices starting around $30,000. Move up the trim range and the amenities expand significantly. Items such as leather seats, a panoramic sunroof, and a full roster of technologies rationalize the higher prices. Notably, a well-equipped Honda CR-V costs about $35,000.
Reliability Comparison
When it comes to safety, which is an aspect of vehicle reliability, the Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV-4 are very close.
In crash testing conducted by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), both models were rated 5 stars, the highest score possible. That testing involves three areas: frontal crash, side crash, and rollover. The NHTSA also recommends certain safety technologies, which both models offer. These are: forward collision warning, lane departure warning, crash imminent braking, and dynamic brake support.
The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) also offers crash testing analysis. Backed by the major insurance companies, the IIHS rates most new vehicles. For 2025, the Honda CR-V received a "Top Safety Pick" award, while the Toyota RAV4 did not. The RAV4 was a previous winner, but this year only the Honda was awarded.
IIHS testing is also more comprehensive than the federal government. The IIHS tests in several categories, including crashworthiness, crash avoidance & mitigation, and seat belts & child restraints. From there, the IIHS drills down to specific types of categories, such as front and side crashes, headlamp quality, and child anchors, among others. In most areas the Honda matched or bested the Toyota, thus the higher score.
As for reliability ratings, a survey of common review sites shows the two models nearly even. These sites include J.D. Power, Edmunds, Consumer Reports, Driven Autos, and Hagerty. When drilling down, Honda received the edge for its engine and transmission. As for Toyota, its hybrid performed marginally better than the Honda. Toyota dominates the hybrid market, but Honda has closed the gap in recent years.
The Verdict: Honda CR-V
While the differences between the NHSTA scores and the reviews are minimal, the Honda CR-V shines with its IIHS crash test rating. Thus, we give the edge to the CR-V in this quest for identifying the best compact SUV.
But do not take our word for it. We invite you to visit Zeigler Honda of Racine to find out. Contact us today to arrange a test drive and to compare gas and hybrid versions of the popular Honda CR-V. Check out the current offers and save big!
